Goadhead

Level 125, Warrior

Halo Guardians

Character

Race: Barbarian

Class: Warrior

Guild: Halo Guardians

Gender: Male

Level: 125

DKP Information

Show the points information for this Char only

Point account name	Earned	Spent	Adjustment	Events: Current	Raids (30 days)	Raids (60 days)	Raids (90 days)	Raids (lifetime)
DKP	3660.00	3539.00	-34.00	87.00	0% (0/0)	0% (0/0)	0% (0/0)	89% (3458/3893)
... 1 entries found

Raids
Items
Adjustments
Raid attendance
Notes

Raid Attendance History

Date	Name	Value
11,15.22	Being Patient	1.00
11,15.22	On Time	1.00
11,14.22	Final Attend	1.00
11,14.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
11,14.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
11,14.22	On Time	1.00
11,13.22	Final Attend	1.00
11,13.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
11,13.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
11,13.22	On Time	1.00
11,08.22	Final Attend	1.00
11,08.22	EoK The Kar'Zok	1.00
11,08.22	EoK Atrebe's Vault	1.00
11,08.22	On Time	1.00
11,07.22	Final Attend	1.00
11,07.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
11,07.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
11,07.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
11,07.22	On Time	1.00
11,06.22	Final Attend	1.00
11,06.22	EoK Chardok Queen	1.00
11,06.22	EoK Chardok Prince	1.00
11,06.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
11,06.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
11,06.22	On Time	1.00
11,01.22	Final Attend	1.00
11,01.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
11,01.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
11,01.22	On Time	1.00
10,30.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,30.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
10,30.22	On Time	1.00
10,25.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,25.22	ToL Zelnithak	1.00
10,25.22	On Time	1.00
10,24.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,24.22	ToL Zelnithak	1.00
10,24.22	On Time	1.00
10,23.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,23.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
10,23.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
10,23.22	On Time	1.00
10,18.22	Being Patient	1.00
10,18.22	On Time	1.00
10,17.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,17.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
10,17.22	On Time	1.00
10,16.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,16.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
10,16.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
10,16.22	On Time	1.00
10,11.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,11.22	CoV Klandicar	1.00
10,11.22	CoV Tantor	1.00
10,11.22	On Time	1.00
10,10.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,10.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
10,10.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
10,10.22	On Time	1.00
10,09.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,09.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
10,09.22	On Time	1.00
10,04.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,04.22	CoV Tantor	1.00
10,04.22	On Time	1.00
10,03.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,03.22	CoV Tantor	1.00
10,03.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
10,03.22	On Time	1.00
10,02.22	Final Attend	1.00
10,02.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
10,02.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
10,02.22	On Time	1.00
09,27.22	Final Attend	1.00
09,27.22	CoV Tantor	1.00
09,27.22	On Time	1.00
09,26.22	Final Attend	1.00
09,26.22	ToL Zelnithak	1.00
09,26.22	On Time	1.00
09,25.22	Final Attend	1.00
09,25.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
09,25.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
09,25.22	On Time	1.00
09,20.22	Final Attend	1.00
09,20.22	ToV Griklor the Restless	1.00
09,20.22	TBL Stratus: Zephyr's Fight	1.00
09,20.22	On Time	1.00
09,19.22	Final Attend	1.00
09,19.22	ToL Zelnithak	1.00
09,19.22	On Time	1.00
09,18.22	Final Attend	1.00
09,18.22	ToL Shei Vinitras	1.00
09,18.22	CoV Zlandicar	1.00
09,18.22	On Time	1.00
09,13.22	Final Attend	1.00
09,13.22	ToL Zelnithak	1.00
09,13.22	On Time	1.00
09,12.22	Final Attend	1.00
09,12.22	CoV Sontalak	1.00
09,12.22	On Time	1.00
... 3458 entries found / 100 are shown

Item Purchase History

Date	Buyer	Name	Raid	Itempool	Value
07,23.24	Goadhead	Valiant Head Armor Lining	LS - Bidils the Quickhand	default	45.00
07,18.24	Goadhead	Sprung Fingercuff	LS - The Return of Kanghammer	default	20.00
07,15.24	Goadhead	Unrelenting Bijou of Hope	LS - Heros Are Forged	default	20.00
07,08.24	Goadhead	Lesser Emblem of the Forge	LS - Heros Are Forged	default	0.00
07,02.24	Goadhead	Lesser Emblem of the Forge	LS - Shadow of My Shadow	default	0.00
06,04.24	Goadhead	Valiant Chest Armor Lining	LS - What is this for?	default	100.00
05,28.24	Goadhead	Valiant Belt Buckle	LS - The Return of Kanghammer	default	47.00
05,13.24	Goadhead	Glowing Emblem of the Forge	LS - Prisoners of Ankexfen Keep	default	0.00
04,23.24	Goadhead	Invictus Warmaker	LS - The Return of Kanghammer	default	1.00
04,22.24	Goadhead	Valiant Wrist Armor Lining	LS - Bidils the Quickhand	default	44.00
04,22.24	Goadhead	Median Emblem of the Forge	LS - Bidils the Quickhand	default	0.00
04,18.24	Goadhead	Minor Emblem of the Forge	LS - Shadow of My Shadow	default	0.00
04,11.24	Goadhead	Median Emblem of the Forge	LS - Bidils the Quickhand	default	0.00
04,02.24	Goadhead	Valiant Leg Armor Lining	LS - The Return of Kanghammer	default	61.00
04,02.24	Goadhead	Minor Emblem of the Forge	LS - Shadow of My Shadow	default	0.00
02,26.24	Goadhead	Valiant Hand Armor Lining	LS - Shadow of My Shadow	default	49.00
02,13.24	Goadhead	Median Emblem of the Forge	LS - Bidils the Quickhand	default	0.00
02,05.24	Goadhead	Valiant Wrist Armor Lining	LS - Bidils the Quickhand	default	32.00
11,07.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Charm Polishing Cloth	NoS The Shadows Move	default	38.00
10,16.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Ring Polishing Cloth	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	21.00
10,10.23	Goadhead	Apparitional String Serving	NoS Myconid Mutiny	default	3.00
10,09.23	Goadhead	Greater Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
10,03.23	Goadhead	Median Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS When one Door Closes	default	0.00
10,03.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Ring Polishing Cloth	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	31.00
09,28.23	Goadhead	Median Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS When one Door Closes	default	0.00
09,26.23	Goadhead	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Shadows Move	default	0.00
09,26.23	Goadhead	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	0.00
08,31.23	Goadhead	Lesser Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
08,24.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Head Armor Lining	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	36.00
08,08.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Arm Armor Lining	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	20.00
07,27.23	Goadhead	Glowing Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
07,10.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Belt Buckle	NoS The Shadows Move	default	51.00
06,29.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Mask Fastner	NoS When one Door Closes	default	31.00
06,20.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Wrist Armor Lining	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	23.00
06,12.23	Goadhead	Greater Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Mean Streat	default	0.00
06,08.23	Goadhead	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Myconid Mutiny	default	0.00
06,06.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Shield Enarmes	NoS When one Door Closes	default	33.00
06,05.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Essence of Finesse	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	23.00
06,01.23	Goadhead	Greater Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS Myconid Mutiny	default	0.00
05,09.23	Goadhead	Minor Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
04,25.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Necklace Clasp	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	75.00
04,24.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Amice Fastener	NoS When one Door Closes	default	41.00
04,20.23	Goadhead	Minor Shadowscribed Parchment	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	0.00
04,17.23	Goadhead	Greater Symbol of Shar Vahl	NoS The Spirit Fades	default	0.00
04,04.23	Goadhead	Minor Shadowscribed Parchment	ToL Zelnithak	default	0.00
04,04.23	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Zelnithak	default	36.00
03,28.23	Goadhead	Greater Shadowscribed Parchment	ToL Zelnithak	default	0.00
03,27.23	Goadhead	Apparitional Wrist Armor Lining	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	41.00
03,20.23	Goadhead	Faded Spectral Luminosity Wrist Armor	NoS Shiknar Queeen	default	22.00
03,16.23	Goadhead	Median Shadowscribed Parchment	ToL Zelnithak	default	0.00
03,09.23	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	27.00
03,07.23	Goadhead	Minor Shadowscribed Parchment	ToL Zelnithak	default	0.00
01,17.23	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Zelnithak	default	31.00
01,09.23	Goadhead	Glowing Shadowscribed Parchment	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	0.00
12,12.22	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	77.00
12,05.22	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	92.00
11,14.22	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	12.00
11,06.22	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	75.00
10,02.22	Goadhead	Glowing Shadowscribed Parchment	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	0.00
08,28.22	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	75.00
07,25.22	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	61.00
07,18.22	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	63.00
06,20.22	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	80.00
05,23.22	Goadhead	Median Shadowscribed Parchment	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	0.00
05,02.22	Goadhead	Calcified Bloodied Ore	ToL Shei Vinitras	default	101.00
04,10.22	Goadhead	Glowing Dragontouched Rune	CoV Zlandicar	default	0.00
03,08.22	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Tantor	default	60.00
11,23.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	51.00
11,01.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Tantor	default	75.00
10,18.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	70.00
10,05.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Tantor	default	70.00
09,26.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	55.00
09,26.21	Goadhead	Greater Kromrif Etching	ToV Griklor the Restless	default	0.00
08,31.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	40.00
08,15.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	41.00
08,10.21	Goadhead	Lesser Kromrif Etching	Kael Drakkel	default	0.00
08,01.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	40.00
07,27.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	45.00
07,13.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	35.00
07,05.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	40.00
07,05.21	Goadhead	Minor Kromrif Etching	ToV Great Divide	default	0.00
06,28.21	Goadhead	Minor Kromrif Etching	ToV Avatar of War	default	0.00
06,27.21	Goadhead	Lesser Dragontouched Rune	CoV Zlandicar	default	0.00
06,27.21	Goadhead	Median Kromrif Etching	ToV Great Divide	default	0.00
06,21.21	Goadhead	Greater Kromrif Etching	Kael Drakkel	default	0.00
05,16.21	Goadhead	Median Dragontouched Rune	CoV Zlandicar	default	0.00
04,25.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Velium Ore Nugget	Kael Drakkel	default	22.00
04,18.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	50.00
04,18.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Velium Ore Nugget	ToV Great Divide	default	50.00
04,12.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Restless Ore	CoV Zlandicar	default	100.00
04,11.21	Goadhead	Lesser Kromrif Etching	ToV Griklor the Restless	default	0.00
04,05.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Velium Ore Nugget	ToV Great Divide	default	20.00
03,29.21	Goadhead	Glowing Kromrif Etching	ToV Great Divide	default	0.00
03,15.21	Goadhead	Median Kromrif Etching	ToV Griklor the Restless	default	0.00
03,14.21	Goadhead	Glowing Dragontouched Rune	CoV Zlandicar	default	0.00
03,01.21	Goadhead	Greater Kromrif Etching	ToV Griklor the Restless	default	0.00
02,21.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Velium Ore Nugget	ToV Griklor the Restless	default	100.00
02,15.21	Goadhead	Diamondized Velium Ore Nugget	ToV Griklor the Restless	default	125.00
07,13.20	Goadhead	Flawless Conflagrant Diamond	RoS Gorowyn	default	2.00
02,24.20	Goadhead	Greater Runes of Kunark	EoK Temple of Droga	default	0.00
... 134 entries found / 100 are shown

Individual Adjustment History

Date	Reason	Value
12,02.23	Adjust	0.50
12,26.22	NewExpansionAdjust	-38.50
02,14.22	New expansion 60 day max level bonus	25.00
12,19.21	New expansion adjustment	-166.00
11,29.16	RBB DKP Transfer	145.00
... 5 entries found

Icon	Event	Raids (lifetime)
	New Event trial	100.00% (4/4)
	Giants Giants Giants	100.00% (1/1)
	Dragons Dragons Dragons	100.00% (3/3)
	Steel Behemoths	100.00% (1/1)
	Lady Vox - HH	100.00% (1/1)
	Legacy Raid	100.00% (9/9)
	Sarith	100.00% (1/1)
	ToV	100.00% (4/4)
	Valley of Lunanyn	100.00% (2/2)
	King of Beasts	100.00% (1/1)
	Lord Nagafen - First Kill	100.00% (2/2)
	Lord Nagafen	100.00% (4/4)
	Grelleth, Her Majesty the Queen	100.00% (6/6)
	Breeding Grounds 2	100.00% (1/1)
	Anniversary	100.00% (7/7)
	Fear	100.00% (3/3)
	Crypt of Sul	100.00% (1/1)
	EoK Chardok Prince	100.00% (17/17)
	Mercenary event	100.00% (2/2)
	Innoruuk	100.00% (2/2)
	Ancients	100.00% (1/1)
	Field of Scale	100.00% (2/2)
	Kurns Tower	100.00% (1/1)
	Council Divided	100.00% (1/1)
	Under Foot	100.00% (7/7)
	Sanctum Somnium	100.00% (9/9)
	Lichen Creep	100.00% (1/1)
	Time and Tides	100.00% (1/1)
	Two Sides of the Stone	100.00% (1/1)
	Lady of Light	100.00% (3/3)
	Order of Three	100.00% (1/1)
	TBM Emollious	100.00% (7/7)
	TBM Grannus	100.00% (1/1)
	Time	100.00% (1/1)
	EoK Lceanium	100.00% (6/6)
	EoK Chardok Queen	100.00% (6/6)
	RoS Catcus	100.00% (7/7)
	EoK Labs	100.00% (1/1)
	TBL Doomfire	100.00% (1/1)
	TBL Stratus: Zephyr's Fight	100.00% (7/7)
	TBM Lady of Life	100.00% (2/2)
	Korascian Warrens: Showdown	100.00% (1/1)
	ToV Seeking the Sorceror	100.00% (6/6)
	CoV Klandicar	100.00% (2/2)
	CoV Three Dragons	100.00% (1/1)
	ToL Aten Ha Ra	100.00% (1/1)
	ToL Zelnithak	100.00% (26/26)
	ToL Netherbian Swarm Commander	100.00% (2/2)
	ToL Oubliette of Light	100.00% (11/11)
	EoK Atrebe's Vault	100.00% (1/1)
	EoK The Kar'Zok	100.00% (1/1)
	NoS Mean Streat	100.00% (15/15)
	RoF Valley of king Xorbb	100.00% (6/6)
	Deathknell	100.00% (1/1)
	Karnor's Castle: Mad Emperor	100.00% (2/2)
	NoS Myconid Mutiny	100.00% (20/20)
	NoS Pit Fight	100.00% (3/3)
	NoS The Artist	100.00% (1/1)
	Paineel: Inner Turmoil	100.00% (1/1)
	LS - The Artisan and the Druid	100.00% (11/11)
	ToL Shei Vinitras	98.00% (86/88)
	EoK Temple of Droga	97.00% (32/33)
	RoS Gorowyn	96.00% (27/28)
	LS - What is this for?	96.00% (23/24)
	ToV Avatar of War	95.00% (21/22)
	CoV Tantor	95.00% (105/110)
	ToV Servant of the Sleeper	95.00% (19/20)
	NoS The Spirit Fades	94.00% (33/35)
	NoS When one Door Closes	93.00% (28/30)
	LS - Heros Are Forged	93.00% (14/15)
	CoV Sontalak	93.00% (27/29)
	LS - Shadow of My Shadow	93.00% (27/29)
	Hate M	92.00% (60/65)
	NoS Shiknar Queeen	92.00% (44/48)
	ToV Griklor the Restless	92.00% (65/71)
	CoV Zlandicar	91.00% (150/164)
	Bixie 1	91.00% (10/11)
	NoS The Shadows Move	90.00% (18/20)
	LS - Bidils the Quickhand	90.00% (27/30)
	LS - The Return of Kanghammer	90.00% (26/29)
	Final Attend	90.00% (829/925)
	On Time	89.00% (904/1011)
	Dead Hills 1	89.00% (32/36)
	Tainted West Karana	88.00% (29/33)
	Breeding Grounds 1	87.00% (33/38)
	LS - Prisoners of Ankexfen Keep	86.00% (12/14)
	Kael Drakkel	85.00% (34/40)
	Crystal Caverns	85.00% (22/26)
	ToV Great Divide	84.00% (42/50)
	TimeStamp	83.00% (232/278)
	Neriak 1	83.00% (5/6)
	TBM Vim and Vigor	81.00% (39/48)
	RoF Shards Landing	80.00% (8/10)
	East Wastes	80.00% (4/5)
	Evantil	80.00% (8/10)
	Dead Hills 2	80.00% (36/45)
	Hate's Fury (17th Anniversary)	79.00% (22/28)
	Tower of Frozen Shadow	75.00% (6/8)
	Bixie 2	75.00% (3/4)
	Being Patient	73.00% (11/15)
	Aaryonar	67.00% (2/3)
	New Expansion Names	67.00% (4/6)
	NoS Under Siege	67.00% (2/3)
	LS - Final Fugue	67.00% (2/3)
	Tainted WK 2	60.00% (3/5)
	Arx Mentis 1	60.00% (6/10)
	ToV Dagarn the Destroyer	57.00% (8/14)
	Neriak 2	53.00% (10/19)
	ToV Lady Mirenilla	50.00% (5/10)
	ToV Jorlleag	40.00% (2/5)
	ToV Sevalak	38.00% (3/8)
	ToV Lord KoiDoken	36.00% (4/11)
	Arx Mentis 2	33.00% (1/3)
	Plane of War	29.00% (2/7)
	Queen Malarian - HARD	0.00% (0/0)
	Queen Malarian	0.00% (0/0)
	Pallarax	0.00% (0/0)
	Pallarax -Hard	0.00% (0/0)
	Crystal Core	0.00% (0/0)
	Rottrued the Twisted	0.00% (0/0)
	FoS 2	0.00% (0/0)
	Vox	0.00% (0/0)
	Black Burrow	0.00% (0/0)
	Venom Lord	0.00% (0/0)
	Venon Lord- Hard	0.00% (0/0)
	Mindblight	0.00% (0/0)
	Mind Shear	0.00% (0/0)
	Trophy Room	0.00% (0/0)
	Stasis	0.00% (0/0)
	Scrying	0.00% (0/0)
	Fippys Revenge	0.00% (0/0)
	Sacrifice	0.00% (0/0)
	Mini - Tower 5.5	0.00% (0/0)
	Generals - 6 tower	0.00% (0/0)
	Frostcrypt	0.00% (0/0)
	Lith Upper Floor	0.00% (0/0)
	Tick Tock	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Deathleaper	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Deathglider	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Bopo	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Bonecracker	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Jorth Hunter of Beast	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Maw Lurker	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Nighthowl	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Thunderpunch	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Willowcrush	0.00% (0/0)
	BD Elder Gotikan	0.00% (0/0)
	Vishimtar	0.00% (0/0)
	Argath 1	0.00% (0/0)
	Demi-Performer	0.00% (0/0)
	Demi-Mayon Mistmore	0.00% (0/0)
	Ritual of Terror	0.00% (0/0)
	Grounds	0.00% (0/0)
	The Well	0.00% (0/0)
	Crushbone - HH	0.00% (0/0)
	Fos 3	0.00% (0/0)
	Epic Fights	0.00% (0/0)
	ToV Cekenar	0.00% (0/0)
	Left Guild	0.00% (0/0)
	ToV Lady Nevederia	0.00% (0/2)
	ToV Aaryonar	0.00% (0/0)
	Tov Lord Feshlak	0.00% (0/0)
	Tov Lord Kreizenn	0.00% (0/0)
	Main Change	0.00% (0/0)
	Argin-Hiz	0.00% (0/0)
	Defense of the City	0.00% (0/2)
	Praetor Vitio	0.00% (0/0)
	RBB DKP Transfer	0.00% (0/0)
	TBM Wither and Decay	0.00% (0/0)
	TBM Damsel of Decay	0.00% (0/0)
	New Expansion adjustment	0.00% (0/0)
	Level bonus	0.00% (0/0)
	ToL Doomshade	0.00% (0/0)
	Gone year or more	0.00% (0/0)
	BOT dkp removal	0.00% (0/0)
	DKP Penalty for overspending DKP	0.00% (0/0)
	Anniversary Bonus	0.00% (0/0)
... 177 entries found

No notes available.

Comments

No comments available.

Halo Guardians DKP

A Drinal Based Everquest Guild

DKP Information

Raid Attendance History

Item Purchase History

Individual Adjustment History

Comments